Mussels are amazing! Great service! Was not a fan of the clam chowder - was a little on the bland side.

The food is delicious, a bit pricey but you know this ahead of time. In the peak of summer it can take long to get a table, but if you're in the hamptons definitely try it

We honeymooned in Montauk and this came as a highly recommended spot for us to visit during our trip. We were able to be seated right away when we walked in because we sat at the bar which was great! We were served water right away and our waiter was so nice. I ordered the poke and my husband ordered a lobster roll. I love the casual neighborhood vibe Bostwick's has. We could overhear the bartender talking to several gentlemen that clearly were frequent customers. Our food was great! They have a patio outside which is always full so if you're wanting to sit outside, I recommend getting there early to get your name in. I would totally come back here and so happy we went!

Love this spot as it's always a go to when we're out east. Prices are high but it's not a surprise when you're taking into account where you're at. The lobster rolls are filled generously with lobster and baked clams are absolutely delicious. Service is always friendly. Get there early before the lunch rush hour especially during the summer time!

Delicious lobster roll and tuna poke, super fresh. Our waitress was friendly and service was great even though they were packed. Overall ambiance was nice too, we were seated by the windows. Would come back if I'm in the area again.

Bostwick's gets a solid 4 because of their awesome hearty lobster bisque and corn chowder. Both extremely flavorful and satisfying on a cool October Saturday. We also ordered some fried oysters and a side of potato salad. While good the remoulade was the stand out and brought the oysters into the party. The roasted corn salsa was missing for the most part on our plate. The potato salad was nice, dill-icious and not too heavy. Service was pretty good and quick. I will say that afternoon I was not prepared for how cold I was about to be while eating our lunch. Will I be back? Sure to pick up the bisque and chowder to bring home. Another oddish thing for a decent size restaurant I believe they only have one private restroom. So when nature calls I sure hope you're not standing in line forever.

Okay, there is a lot of things I really like about this place: a. The food has healthy portions of Lobster - like double to triple what you would expect b. The staff is lovely friendly, and super thoughtful c. Feels like neighborhood cook out vibe - very appropriate Why it didn't get 5 stars: - This place is always crazy packed, with not enough parking and 1 to 2 hour waits. Oh and they don't take reservations Good for: 1. Lobster lovers 2. Small group trips 3. People who don't mind waiting 1 to 2 hours for good food 4. Pretty good prices for Hamptons (still sticker shock) Bad for: 1. Break ups - you will be waiting a while 2. Kids 3. People who like fancy lobster

Stopped here for lunch with friends on a trip. We were a big group and it was a Saturday, so we had to wait awhile as expected but this was totally fine. We were seated outside at 1 large table which we appreciated rather than being split up. We got several items and I'll give a short description on each. Cold lobster roll - my personal favorite. I prefer cold ones over hot. It wasn't as big as I expected it to be, but it was still a decent size and a fair amount of lobster meat with large chunks. Comes with a side and I got cole slaw, which I didn't love that much but it wasn't bad either. Wish I got fries or potato salad instead. Hot lobster roll - those who got it, really liked it but noted that it looked like the cold ones might've had more meat. Fried clam strips - fine, but not amazing. Calamari - really good and fried nicely, not too oily. Raw oysters - good, pretty average but not bad. New England clam chowder - really good, but could be thicker. Wasn't watery though, I just like a thicker chowder but good amount of celery, clams, and potatoes. Comes with a packet of oyster crackers too. Lobster bisque - nice portion of lobster bits and solid. I preferred the clam chowder when doing side by side comparison. Mixed greens salad - average, typical green salad. Arugula salad - favorite among the table and especially if you like blue cheese! Shrimp cocktail - refreshing and good, but not amazing. Seafood pasta - really generous portion and lots of seafood. A good option if you don't want a sandwich or fried food. Service was great and we enjoyed the meal. Parking lot is small and can be confusing. Overall, table favorites were probably oysters, lobster rolls, arugula salad, and the chowder/bisque. A nice stop if you're in the area for sure!

Stopped by for lunch on our way to Montauk. Great location, decor and ambiance. Ordered lobster rolls, softshell crab sandwich and clam chowder. All delicious and portion generous. Will definitely be our go to if in the area again.

I loved everything I got here. I started with a Bloody Mary. It was a really good Bloody Mary. All their drinks I tried were really good. It was seasoned perfectly and had a nice spice to it. Then we got an order of the oysters. The oysters were small, but they were still really good. I would get them again. I got the lobster roll and it was so good. There was a lot of lobsters in the roll. The lobsters were buttery and tender. The meat was sweet with the buttery bun. I loved the clam chowder, but I felt like there was not enough seafood in it. All in all, a great spot to stop by to get a lobster roll.